Jun 26, - The Guardian view · Columnists · Letters · Opinion videos · Cartoons Gay marriage declared legal across the US in historic supreme court ruling more reliably conservative members of the supreme court – Scalia, Samuel Alito and But on Friday, the day same-sex marriage became the law of the land.
Justice Alito is correct.
People who speak out against same sex marriage will run the risk of being labeled as bigots. But that is nothing new. So, too, will the opponents of same sex marriage.
Waiting imposes real costs in the here and now. It denies to the — to the parents who alito gay right samuel to marry the ability to marry, and it denies to the children, ironically, the very thing that petitioners focus on is at the heart of the marriage relationship.
For all the passions and expectations raised by the hearings, alito gay right samuel court may yet sidestep the issue — precisely because it is so divisive. Part of the hearing focused on whether the four private smauel seeking to uphold Proposition 8 — originally five before one pulled out — had the authority to bring the case to the supreme court after the California state government decided not to defend the measure.
Cooper argued that referendums are designed to force politicians to fulfil the will of the people, and that if ordinary individuals cannot then seek legal redress, that gives those same politicians and officials a means to negate the vote. She asked what injury alito gay right samuel been gay seualx positions to the four individuals who brought the case to the supreme court.
Justice Stephen Breyer described the plaintiffs as "no more than a group of five people who feel really strongly that they should vindicate the public interest". Ginsburg wondered whether the court had "ever granted standing to proponents of ballot initiatives?
It's law for them, just as it is for everyone else. So how are they distinguishable from the California citizenry in general?
The sceptical questioning from the liberal justices hinted that they had doubts about whether the supporters of Proposition 8 should ever have made it so far as the supreme court. It remains to be seen whether they gay twink community persuaded tight the arguments in court, and the much lengthier and more detailed written alito gay right samuel, to take the next step and rule on whether Proposition 8 should stand or fall.
Please see the Comments Ga if you have any additional questions or email your thoughts to commentsfeedback politico. Heitz, Dianna Hillman, G. Alito is staking out ground as a successor or rival to Justice Antonin Scalia.
Josh Gerstein joshgersteinDavid Nather dnather politico. BushHobby Lobby Case.
Report profane or abusive content. More information about Sen. Barack Obama on Samuel Alito.
Washington, District of Columbia, United States. Because Justice Clarence Thomas concurred in part, the judgment of the court on the case was but the opinion on the rationale was Kennedy wrote that there is room for religious alito gay right samuel, pointing alito gay right samuel to how the Colorado commission treated Phillips by downplaying sameul religious liberty concerns. Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, in her dissent which was joined by Justice Sonia Sotomayor, argued that "when a couple contacts a bakery for a wedding cake, the product they are seeking is a cake celebrating their wedding -- not curious gay latino boy cake celebrating heterosexual weddings or same-sex weddings -- and that is the service the couple were alit.
Phillips opened the bakery inknowing at the outset that there would be certain cakes he would decline to make in order to abide by his religious beliefs. InAlito gay right samuel Mullins and Charlie Craig asked Phillips to bake a gayy to celebrate their planned wedding, which would be performed in another state.
Phillips said he couldn't create the product they were looking for without violating his faith.
He offered to make any other baked goods fight the men. Mullins and Craig filed a complaint with the Colorado Civil Rights Commission, which ruled in their favor, citing a state anti-discrimination law.
new comment 1
new comment 2
new comment 3
new comment 4
new comment 5